Is Overtime Pay Taxed Differently? Everything You Need to Know

Understanding the rules around the tax on overtime is crucial for both employees and employers, especially with the 2025 changes in U.S. tax law. Let’s break down exactly how overtime pay is taxed, what’s new for 2025–2028, and common misconceptions to ensure clarity on this important topic.

What Is Overtime Pay?

Overtime pay is compensation earned for working beyond the standard hours, typically more than 40 hours per week. Federal law (FLSA) requires employers to pay nonexempt employees at a rate of 1.5 times their standard hourly wage for each overtime hour. This rule applies to both salary and hourly workers unless the employee is exempt, such as certain professionals or executives.

Is Tax on Overtime Different from Regular Tax?

No, there is no special tax rate for overtime pay. The tax on overtime is calculated using the same federal income tax rates, Social Security, and Medicare tax rates as your regular wages. Employers withhold taxes from the sum total of your regular and overtime pay in each pay period.

Some confusion arises when larger paychecks (from overtime work) appear to have more taxes taken out. But the rate remains the same, it's just that earning more increases your overall tax liability if your annual income crosses into a higher bracket. For accurate filing, many employees turn to an offshore tax preparation to ensure deductions and credits are applied correctly.

What Changed in 2025–2028? The New Federal Overtime Deduction

A major update for tax years 2025 through 2028 is the new federal deduction for overtime pay introduced under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA). Here’s what it means for workers:

  • You can deduct up to $12,500 (single) or $25,000 (married filing jointly) of qualifying overtime pay from your taxable income.
  • This deduction phases out at higher income levels: $150,000 for single filers; $300,000 for married filing jointly.
  • Only the time-and-a-half portion of overtime pay counts for the deduction.
  • This deduction applies only to federal income tax; payroll taxes like Social Security and Medicare still apply.

Tax on Overtime: Calculation Example

To understand how overtime tax is applied, let’s compare the old system (before 2025) with the new rules under OBBBA 2025–2028.

  • Old System (pre-2025):
    An employee earns $800 in regular pay for 40 hours and an additional $300 for 10 hours of overtime at $30/hour. Since there were no deductions for overtime pay, the entire $1,100 counted as taxable income.

  • New System (2025–2028):
    The same employee still makes $800 in regular pay and $300 in overtime. However, under the updated law, the time-and-a-half portion of overtime pay qualifies for a $100 deduction. This reduces the taxable income to $1,000 instead of $1,100.
  • In the new system, only the “premium” portion the $10 extra per overtime hour counts for the deduction. So 10 hours x $10 = $100 deductible from federal taxable income, if under the income threshold.
  • Regular and overtime pay are always subject to FICA (Social Security and Medicare) regardless of the deduction.

Do States Tax Overtime the Same Way?

Most U.S. states apply the same tax rates to overtime as regular income. A few states, such as California, have stricter wage laws but no special state income tax rate for overtime pay. Always check state-specific rules for compliance.

Common Misconceptions About Tax on Overtime

  • "Overtime pushes my whole income to a higher tax rate." Only the income above a tax bracket threshold is taxed at the higher rate, not your entire paycheck.
  • "There’s a special 'overtime tax.'" There is no separate federal or state tax for overtime earnings. Payroll systems simply apply normal tax tables to your increased gross pay.
  • "I shouldn’t take overtime because I’ll lose money on taxes." Earning more always increases net take-home pay, though you may see slightly more withheld if you’re in a higher bracket.

Final Thoughts on Tax on Overtime

For most workers, the tax on overtime is straightforward. Overtime is simply added to your regular income and taxed by the same rules. With the recent OBBBA changes, many will see reduced taxable income from overtime in 2025–2028 if they qualify. Always check the latest IRS guidance and keep detailed payroll records for the best outcome at tax time.

FAQs about Tax on Overtime

Is overtime pay taxed differently than regular pay?

No, overtime pay is taxed using the same rates and rules as regular pay.

What is the "No Tax on Overtime" law?

The OBBBA allows workers to deduct up to $12,500 ($25,000 joint) of qualified overtime income from federal taxable income, applying only for 2025–2028 and phasing out at higher incomes.

Does Social Security tax apply to overtime pay?

Yes, Social Security and Medicare (FICA) taxes apply to all taxable income, including overtime pay.

Does taking overtime always increase my tax bracket?

No, only if your additional earnings move your total annual income above the next tax threshold, and only the excess is taxed at the higher rate.

How do I claim the overtime deduction at tax time?

Retain your pay records and ensure that your W-2 (or 1099, if eligible) separately states qualified overtime pay. The deduction is claimed on your federal tax return for years 2025–2028.

Enlist Accritic Chartered Accountants as Your Firm's Virtual Back Office

We help accounting firms, bookkeepers & CPA's gain capacity.

Get a Quote for Your Firm